Introduction:
Introduction:
SP3D (Smart Plant 3D) and E3D (AVEVA Everything3D) are two leading software products for the 3D design of plants and related engineering. Both systems are the mainstays of complicated capital projects, in particular, those in the energy, process, and marine industries. They help engineers develop extremely precise, intelligent, and clash-free digital representations of enormous industrial facilities. On top of these, such platforms form the basis for enhancing the overall design, mitigating the material waste, and hence, fast-tracking the construction process considerably. These two, however, still have a lot of differences, namely their features, user interfaces, and workflows, because they come from different heritages.
Core Functionality and Design Philosophy:
Core Functionality and Design Philosophy:
SP3D and E3D provide features for the creation of piping, steel structures, plant equipment, and HVAC systems extensively. SP3D, which is a product of Intergraph (now Hexagon), is largely associated with its firmly rule-governed design automation. It imparts the instant implementation of the standards and constraints of the design. On the other hand, E3D, with its origin traced to the PDMS platform of AVEVA, features an efficient and friendly interface and a potent object-centric data model. Both of them aim at separate levels of design workflow management, albeit with the same overall process.
- SP3D relies on compelling rule-based design automation to facilitate compliance.
- By means of design constraints, it makes sure that the components remain within the specifications automatically.
- E3D affords a nearly perfect and modern user interface (UI), which is highly intuitive.
- E3D derived its features from the mature and widely known AVEVA PDMS platform.
- Both packages have the same utility for the modelling of piping, structural steel, and equipment.
- Moreover, they are very helpful in the performance of clash detection, which is an issue of great concern in the plant design industry.
Piping and Routing Capabilities:
Piping and Routing Capabilities:
The piping design is the centerpiece of the plant design software, and it is also the most difficult to accomplish. SP3D relies on its spec-driven routing engine to do this routing work with style. To be more specific, this routing engine takes the pipe specs and routing rules as inputs and then, within a very short time, a route of an extremely complex network of pipes is generated, so that such manuals will not be able to produce errors. On the other hand, E3D unveils flexible and interactive piping approaches, through which the designer may conveniently and swiftly manipulate both the routing and the properties of components. Both systems are designed in such a way that they take care of essential elements such as flanges, gaskets and bolts in a manner invisible to one, while at the same time providing an efficient method for the accurate materials take-offs (MTOs).
- SP3D utilises a very strict, specification-driven routing method.
- The method automatically chooses the materials based on the pipe specifications that have been defined.
- E3D allows users to navigate the 3D space more dynamically and interactively, making the routing changes more easily and quickly.
- Both systems are designed to make the end products of the MTOs and BOMs extremely accurate in a completely automatic manner.
- They make certain that the necessary installation of pipe support and hanging can be carried out without a hitch.
- Besides, the software proactively addresses every element directly from fabrication by the detailed isometric drawings it generates.
Structural Modelling and Detailing:
Structural Modelling and Detailing:
The structural module of both packages serves the purpose of engineering and visualising the plant's supporting framework. SP3D leads in detailed structural designs of high caliber, and it makes connections, splices, and footings that are in line with the national codes without human intervention. Besides, its connection to other SmartPlant tools facilitates smoother workflows in structural analysis. The structural module of E3D, thus, its object database, can work with voluminous and complicated steel structures without breaking a sweat. It changes to a more comfortable way by using software for the modelling of beams, columns, and bracing and for the subsequent structural analysis.
- SP3D allows for detailed and advanced structural connection work and also for connection placement.
- It automatically does complex things such as stairs, ladders, and platforms, without human intervention.
- E3D is a very potent tool when it comes to the modelling of big steel trusses and frames.
- In addition, both give their users the ability to describe and locate foundations and concrete components.
- They also offer capabilities for the creation of structural fabrication drawings.
- Also, they offer the possibility to be integrated with Finite Element Analysis (FEA) software.
Data Management and Interoperability:
Data Management and Interoperability:
The intelligence of these models lies in the database connectivity of the 3D objects. SP3D works on the SmartPlant Enterprise data environment that supports the interoperability of the entire engineering tool suite of Hexagon by the way of data exchange. Joints of design, documentation, and asset management tools become quite smooth and easy with this software package. Meanwhile, AVEVA's E3D keeps the high data quality standard through a very solid platform, namely, AVEVA Information Management. Both can work with large databases and are good enough to concurrently design sessions by multiple users. To learn more, one can visit the E3D Course.
- SP3D is deeply integrated within the entire Hexagon SmartPlant Enterprise ecosystem.
- E3D derives maximum advantage from its core PDMS object database in terms of data integrity.
- Both support multi-user environments for concurrent design access.
- They produce industry-standard files such as PCF (Piping Component File).
- Besides, interoperability is also carried on via such formats as IFC (Industry Foundation Classes).
- Report generation from the model data is another feature provided by these intelligent data models.
Ease of Use and Learning Curve:
Ease of Use and Learning Curve:
Usually, the user experience, along with the training necessities, is the main deciding factor for companies while choosing a platform. E3D is most often praised for its more updated, illustrated interface and probably a more rapid learning curve for beginners. The transition of PDMS to E3D was very easy for most users because it was an evolution they were already familiar with. SP3D, on the other hand, is still very powerful, but quite infamous for its complicated nature and a steeper learning curve due to its being strongly rule-based. Generally, extensive training is needed to be able to command the advanced rule writing and customisation features. Preparing for the E3D Interview Questions can help you start a promising career in this domain.
- E3D will usually provide a more user-friendly and visually appealing contemporary interface.
- New users might consider that the learning curve of E3D is relatively more rapid.
- SP3D users will need a lot more training if they wish to fully utilise the automation features of the program.
- E3D is very much backwards compatible with the existing PDMS projects and data.
- Both demand specialised skills, which usually end up in a certification process.
- The greatest option will almost always rely on the particular circumstances of the project and the country of origin.
Conclusion:
Conclusion:
Intergraph SP3D and AVEVA E3D are two top-of-the-line solutions that the industry can rely on to skillfully create 3D plants without resulting in clashes. The rule-based automation in SP3D, together with the close ties to the Hexagon suite, makes it a good match for projects with requirements of high compliance requirements. E3D, on the other hand, has been recognised for keeping up with its strong heritage, having a modern interface and interaction, and is preferred for speed and flexibility. Many institutions provide SP3D Training, and enrolling in them can help you start a career in this domain. Usually, it is the difference between user standards of the company, the intricate nature of the project, and the degree of design automation chosen against the simplicity of the user interface that makes the decision.
Attachments
-
E3D.jpeg